Student Loans: The Complete Guide to Borrowing Smart

Student loan debt in America stands at $1.77 trillion across 43.2 million borrowers [1]NY Fed Household Debt and Credit Report, 2024. The average balance is $37,650. Some of those borrowers are fine. Many are not. The difference almost always comes down to how much they borrowed and whether they understood the terms. This guide covers the essentials.

Federal vs. Private Loans: Know the Difference[2]Federal Student Aid, Federal Loan Types, 2024-25

Always exhaust federal loans before considering private ones. This isn't opinion; it's math.

Federal Loan Types and Limits[2]Federal Student Aid, Federal Loan Types, 2024-25

Aggregate limits:

• Dependent undergrad: $31,000 (max $23,000 subsidized)
• Independent undergrad: $57,500 (max $23,000 subsidized)[2]Federal Student Aid, Federal Loan Types, 2024-25

The Unsubsidized Interest Trap

Here's how interest capitalization burns you. On a $5,500 unsubsidized loan at 6.53%:

Multiply that across four years of borrowing, and you can graduate owing $3,000–$5,000 more than you borrowed, before making a single payment. If you can afford to pay interest while in school, do it.

Average Debt by School Type[3]NCES Digest of Education Statistics, 2024

For-Profit 4-Year

$39.9k

Private Nonprofit 4-Year

$33.5k

Public 4-Year (Out-of-State)

$32.8k

Public 4-Year (In-State)

$29.4k

Notice the for-profit debt-to-income ratio: 1.18. That means the average for-profit graduate owes more than their entire first year's salary. That's the danger zone.

Rule of thumb: Total student debt should not exceed your expected first year's salary. Ideally, keep it under 50% of expected salary.

Repayment Plans[2]Federal Student Aid, Federal Loan Types, 2024-25

Federal loans offer multiple repayment options:

The SAVE Plan (Current as of 2024)

The SAVE plan is the most generous IDR option currently available (though it has faced legal challenges, check current status):

• Undergraduate loans: 5% of discretionary income
• Graduate loans: 10% of discretionary income
• Discretionary income threshold: income above 225% of poverty line (~$33,885 for single filer)
• $0 payments if income is below threshold
• Forgiveness after 20 years (undergrad) or 25 years (grad)
• Unpaid interest does not capitalize

Note: The SAVE plan has been subject to ongoing litigation. Check studentaid.gov for the latest status before relying on it.

Loan Forgiveness Programs

Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)

• Requirement: 120 qualifying payments (10 years) while working full-time for a qualifying employer (government, nonprofit)
• Forgiveness amount: Remaining balance after 120 payments, tax-free
• Qualifying employers: Federal/state/local government, 501(c)(3) nonprofits, some other nonprofits
• Payments that count: Must be on an IDR plan or Standard 10-year plan
• Borrowers who've received PSLFPublic Service Loan Forgiveness: a federal program forgiving loans after 10 years of public service payments: 1,039,000+ as of 2024 [2]Federal Student Aid, Federal Loan Types, 2024-25

PSLF was notoriously difficult to obtain before 2021 reforms. The approval rate has improved dramatically but still requires careful documentation. Use the PSLF Help Tool at studentaid.gov.

IDR Forgiveness

Any remaining balance after 20–25 years on an IDR plan is forgiven. However: under current tax law, IDR forgiveness (unlike PSLF) is treated as taxable income after 2025 (the current tax-free treatment expires December 31, 2025, unless extended by Congress).

Teacher Loan Forgiveness

• Up to $17,500 forgiven after 5 years teaching in a low-income school
• Must have Direct Loans or FFEL loans
• Can be combined with PSLF (but not for the same service years)

Private Loans: When and How

Consider private loans only after:

1. Maxing out federal subsidized loans
2. Maxing out federal unsubsidized loans
3. Exhausting scholarships and grants
4. Considering whether you should attend a cheaper school instead

If you do borrow privately:

How Much Is Too Much?

Financial planners generally recommend that total monthly loan payments not exceed 10% of gross monthly income. At $50,000/year salary, that's $417/month, enough to service about $36,500 in loans on a standard plan.[5]Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024

Bottom Line

Borrow federal first, borrow only what you need, and never borrow more than your expected first year's salary. Understand your repayment options before you sign the promissory note, not after. The students who get crushed by student debt aren't unlucky; they borrowed without doing the math. Do the math.

---